Cross-border infection

People-to-people contacts and AIDS

If India fears cross-border infiltration by terrorists, Pakistan fears cross-border infection — especially by the HIV/AIDS. Dr Srichand Ochani, the chief of the AIDS Control Programme of Pakistan’s Sindh province, believes that given the prevalence of HIV/AIDS in India “growing cross-border mobilisation of the populations of the two countries could lead to a further increase in the ratio of such a lethal disease”. According to Dr Ochani, the Pakistani government is considering HIV-screening tests for people traveling to or coming from India.

Referring to a study about sex workers in Mumbai, his colleague Dr Sharfuddin Shah feared that since Mumbai is more ‘liberal’ than Karachi, frequent mobility between the two mega cities will mainly affect the people of Karachi.

Ironically, Dr Shah percieves India as a good source of anti-HIV drugs too. “We’ll greatly benefit from normalisation of our relations when we purchase medicines to cure HIV/AIDS from India at cheaper rates. India is the largest supplier of these drugs, while we do not import a single drug for the disease legally,” he said.

The exact incidence of HIV/AIDS in Pakistan is something of a mystery. According to the Pakistani government, there are only 2741 cases in Pakistan, while the WHO puts this as closer to 80,000. Dr Shah’s own estimates put the number of in the range of hundreds of thousands.

The Pakistani health authorities are justified in taking adequate precautions to ensure that the increasing volume of human traffic does not end up resulting in public health problems. However, as long as Pakistan’s own AIDS situation remains obfuscated, they may be focusing their energies on the wrong threat. The drug-addicts of Larkana may pose a greater danger than the sex-workers of Mumbai.

8 thoughts on “Cross-border infection”

  1. Pingback: Simon World
  2. Pingback: vichaar.org
  3. This Pakistani policy reeks of political one-upmanship.

    Although it is acknowledged that India has more HIV+ individuals because of a higher population, the “density” of the infection (total number HIV positive individuals per every thousand individuals) has to be same throughout the subcontinent (If not higher in Pakistan and Bangladesh whose health programs are a lot more dubious than Indian health programs)

    Plus, though India has a higher population – the number of Indians visiting Pakistan and the number of Pakistanis visiting India *legally* is roughly equal (discounting cross-border terrorists whose cross-overs are unaccounted) if not more on the Pakistani side.

    If anything, India should fear HIV *from Pakistan* more than Pakistan should fear HIV *from India*

    Pakistan better stop resorting to such cheapshot tactics for scoring political points

  4. I’m posting a *primitive* trackback to this entry on my blog (It wont be a real trackback – blogger doesn’t offer trackbacks)

Comments are closed.