with rgds,
niraj kumar
mo-9909907961

…..

To know how Reservations have uplifted the society, see the MBBS Admissions

Open Seats – 430

321 BC students,
57 MBC students
14 SC students will get into the open competition.
38 Forward Community

This literally means that students from BC (321) and MBC (57) score well than the Forward Community (38) Counterparts

This also means that the students from the so called forward community are able to get LESS THAN 10 percent of seats available……

That is if 430 seats are available forward community gets 38

If 100 seats are available Forward Community will get 9 seats (38*100/430)

If 81 seats are available Forward Community will get 8 seats (38*85/430)

So WHEN 100 seats are available

WITHOUT RESERVATION
FOrward Community will get 9 seats

WITH 18 % reservation for SC and 1 % reservation for ST
Forward Community is getting 8 seats

That means, reservation is giving JUST ONE OUT OF THE 100 Seats from Forward Community to the SC and ST

Why then there is such a huge cry against Reservation ??

General – 97.75%
BC – 97 %
MBC – 95.5%
SC – 94 %
ST – 90 %

This is what happens when you give reservation ….

Now, I am sure that the author understand as to why the students from backward communities will work hard…..

By the way, Nitin, what is your opinion about Institute Quota in AIIMS.. Why no one is opposing that …. Can you please explain

To get the college of his choice and course of his choice….

To get into COmp Science in Anna University, the difference between OC, BC and MBC cut offs are marginal

Same for Medical Colleges also

Does this gentleman know that the cut off for MBBS in tamil Nadu (with history of reservation for decades)

// And why would the marginal student in the engineering college attempt to score top grades, when quotas guarantee a government job? //

To get the job of his choice and place of his choice

//And why would the marginal government employee strive for excellence if promotions can be had with far less effort, as long as there is a quota?//

This is the most stupid argument i have seen (of course most – though not all – of anti reservation arguments are stupid)

Promotion irrespective of performance is guaranteed for EVERY ONE IRRESPECTIVE OF QUOTAs….

To finesse a possible adverse Supreme Court judgment in the quota case, I suggest that the UPA Government immediately pass the Performance With Social Justice Act of 2007. All Educational institutions must reserve the top grade (A-, A, or A+) in exams according to this egalitarian and socially just formula: 22.5% for the SC/ST students, 27% for the OBC, 15% for Muslims, 2% for Christians, 2% for Sikhs, 33% for girls, … Oops, am I overshooting 100%? Heck, why not a few percentage points error when social justice is at stake?

Yes. It counts. But doesn’t even scratch the surface as far as reforming the civil service is concerned.

Just a query though, I may be wrong.

Capitalism is the unequal distribution of wealth, communism is the equal distribution of poverty.